Like some TV shows and movies, there are a few paintings that have captivated viewers by directly addressing them, whether through the subject of the painting, an inscription, or a hidden detail. This technique creates a sense of intimacy and engagement, drawing the observer into the artwork’s narrative. We’ve seen this done throughout art history, whether through Jan van Eyck’s The Arnolfini Portrait of the Northern Renaissance or René Magritte’s surrealist The Treachery of Images.
The Arnolfini Portrait by Jan van Eyck
The Arnolfini Portrait, Jan van Eyck. Photograph taken at The National Gallery, London in 2022.
At first glance, Flemish painter Jan van Eyck’s The Arnolfini Portrait depicts a scene of a merchant, Giovanni Arnolfini, and his wife, Costanza Trenta, in their home.
Central to the painting is a convex mirror that reflects not only the couple but also two additional figures, believed to be van Eyck himself and a witness. This reflection invites viewers to look beyond the immediate scene, adding layers to the context of the painting.
Above the mirror, van Eyck boldly inscribed "Johannes de Eyck fuit hic" ("Jan van Eyck was here"), asserting his presence in the scene. This inclusion of the artist’s signature within the depicted environment is a classic example of breaking the fourth wall, acknowledging both the creator and the viewer.
The Arnolfini Portrait, Jan van Eyck. Photograph taken at The National Gallery, London in 2022.
Las Meninas by Diego Velázquez
Diego Velázquez’s Las Meninas' emphasis on composition and perspective was renowned for its complex interplay between the figures in the painting and the viewer.
The painting features a large mirror in the background reflecting King Philip IV and Queen Mariana, who are presumably standing where the viewer would be. The central figure, the Infanta Margarita, along with Velázquez himself, painted at his easel, looks out of the painting. This setup creates a dynamic interaction, as the observer is placed within the scene, becoming part of the royal audience.
Velázquez’s inclusion of himself in the act of painting, the reflected images of the royal couple, and the various gazes directed towards the viewer all serve to break the fourth wall. The painting becomes a complex narrative that involves and engages the observer in multiple layers of reality and representation.
The Ambassadors by Hans Holbein the Younger
Hans Holbein the Younger's The Ambassadors is a double portrait that masterfully combines realism and symbolism to engage the viewer in an interactive experience. The painting depicts two wealthy, well-dressed men surrounded by various scientific instruments and luxury items, symbolizing their knowledge and status.
However, what truly sets this work apart is the inclusion of an anamorphic skull, distorted at the bottom of the canvas. This skull, which can only be properly viewed from a specific angle, serves as a memento mori, reminding viewers of the inevitability of death. The direct gazes of the ambassadors, combined with this hidden image, draw the observer into a contemplation of both the depicted subjects and the deeper philosophical themes of mortality and the transient nature of life.
Christ Blessing by Gerard David
Gerard David’s Christ Blessing features a serene and compassionate Christ figure extending a blessing to the viewer. The composition and gaze of Christ create a direct interaction with the observer. The subject’s eyes meet those of the viewer, and his raised hand, mid-blessing, reaches out as if to include them in the sacred moment. This direct engagement transcends the boundary of the painting, inviting the viewer into a spiritual and personal encounter.
Interested in learning more about art history? Explore online courses and in-person short courses at Sotheby's Institute.
The Treachery of Images by René Magritte
René Magritte’s The Treachery of Images challenges perceptions and assumptions with its iconic image of a pipe and the inscription "Ceci n'est pas une pipe" ("This is not a pipe").
By combining the visual image with contradictory text, Magritte forces the viewer to confront the difference between reality and representation. This playful interaction directly addresses and questions the viewer’s understanding of art and meaning. Magritte’s work extends beyond simple representation, engaging viewers in a philosophical inquiry about art, language, and perception.
The Luncheon on the Grass by Édouard Manet
Édouard Manet’s The Luncheon on the Grass was revolutionary for its time, depicting a nude woman casually lounging with two fully dressed men in a forest setting. The woman gazes directly at the viewer, challenging social conventions and the viewer's comfort. This direct engagement, combined with the modern subject matter, creates a thought-provoking interaction between the painting and its audience.
Trompe-l’Oeil Still Life with Flower Garland and Curtain by Adriaen van der Spelt and Frans van Mieris
Trompe-l’Oeil Still Life with Flower Garland and Curtain is a masterful example of illusionistic painting. “Trompe l’Oeil”, or “to deceive the eye” in French, is a technique that some artists used to depict an object in their painting with the intention of tricking the viewer into believing the object is real. The depiction of a curtain partially drawn back to reveal a still life creates the illusion of depth and reality, inviting the viewer to peek behind the curtain. This playful and interactive approach breaks the fourth wall, engaging the observer in a visual and conceptual exploration of art and reality.
Portrait of a Carthusian by Petrus Christus
Petrus Christus's Portrait of a Carthusian includes a trompe l'Oeil fly on the painted frame, creating the illusion that the insect is sitting on the painting's surface. “Musca depicta”, or “painted fly” in Latin, was a popular art technique in the 15th-17th centuries, initially included in paintings with the purpose of proving the painter’s skill. The musca depicta eventually evolved into a dark symbol as many saw the fly as a sign of death and impermanence.
Want to learn more about Art History? Sotheby's Institute offers learning options from online course to in-person short courses.